UPS Center
Week 10 recap

UPS CENTER

At the desk: Stuart & Rich · Kenny Mayne in the Coffee Shop

Bear Dunn scored 308.9 in Week 10, the best score of the week, and beat all eleven teams in All-Play. Week 10 recap, built from the league’s own data; an editor has not reviewed it.

1 The Big Story — Bear Dunn is on a historic pace
Stuart

Bear Dunn scored 308.9 in Week 10, the best score of the week, and beat all eleven teams in All-Play. Bear Dunn swept all 3 games: Josh Martel by 173.9, Ryan Bousquet by 76.4, and Keith Creelman by 58.1. Bear Dunn is 24–3 overall and 99–11 in All-Play.

Stuart

Bear Dunn scored 308.9 in Week 10: the 7th-highest single-week score and the 26th-best share of the league average among the 2,724 team-weeks since 2011 (playoffs and this season included).

Rich

Bear Dunn has beaten at least nine of the eleven other teams in each of the last 9 weeks. Only one regular-season team since 2011 has had a streak that long: Josh Martel in 2018 (10 weeks).

Kenny

Ryan Bousquet put it in the chat Sunday at 2:31 PM: “I’m coming for you, mofos. I may even hit 210 this week! Check your rearview mirror, Bear.🤦‍♂️”, and then at 2:32 PM: “You would need a 22nd-century rearview”. Ryan Bousquet scored 232.5 that week and lost to Bear Dunn by 76.4.

Rich

Here is what 99–11 means. Since 2011, 180 teams have reached Week 10 with a full record in the league archive. Exactly one had a better All-Play record at this point: Josh Martel’s 2018 team, which was 103–7.

Stuart

That is .900 for Bear Dunn. Josh Martel’s 2018 start was .936. After Bear Dunn, the next best starts are Derrick Whitman’s 2015 team at 85–25 and the 2013 team at 84–26, then Steve Bousquet’s 2017 team at 84–26.

Rich

And 2018 is the part worth sitting with. That team finished 25–1 with a 155–21 All-Play record, the best full season in the archive, and still lost the final. A great start is not a title.

Stuart

Bear Dunn knows both ends of this. In 2021 the start was 28–82 in All-Play at this point. Now it is 99–11 with a 99.99% chance at the first-round bye and a 52.2% chance at the title in the forecast. The next best title odds belong to Eric Martel at 23.6%.

Best All-Play starts through Week 10, 2011–2026Through Week 10PctHow the season ended
2018 · Josh Martel103–7.936Lost the final
2026 · Bear Dunn99–11.900In progress
2015 · Derrick Whitman85–25.773Third
2013 · Derrick Whitman84–26.764Champion
2017 · Steve Bousquet84–26.764Champion

All-Play counts every team’s weekly score against all eleven others, Weeks 1–10 of the regular season. Source: the league archive of weekly results, 2011–2025, plus the 2026 standings. 2010 is left out because its archived weekly scores conflict with themselves. The finish is the archive’s final standing.

Stuart

The other story of the week arrived Tuesday, and it was big: Eric Martel and Brian Cross made an eight-asset trade at 5:02 AM ET. Eric Martel sent Jordan Addison (WR), Brian Cross’s 2027 first-round pick, Brian Cross’s 2027 second-round pick, and Eric Martel’s 2027 fifth-round pick. Cross sent Trevor Lawrence (QB), Keith Creelman’s 2027 first-round pick, Derrick Whitman’s 2027 third-round pick, and $18,000 of cap space.

Rich

The players Eric Martel sent carry $17,000 in salary, and the players Cross sent carry $37,000. Only 66 of the 1,036 trades in league history since 2010 moved eight assets or more.

Stuart

Cross had given Eric Martel his own 2027 first-round and second-round picks in April for Jalen Hurts. Tuesday’s trade brought both picks back.

Stuart

Jordan Addison is hurt. Minnesota placed him on injured reserve with a thumb injury and expects him back in about four weeks from November 16. That is an estimate, not a date. Source: Vikings, November 16. Cross said himself that he wanted draft capital, not immediate help.

Rich

With Addison on Cross’s active roster, Eric Martel gives up Addison’s $17,000 salary, takes on Lawrence’s $37,000 salary, and receives $18,000 of cap space. That makes Lawrence an additional $2,000 of 2026 cap cost for Eric Martel. Eric Martel still owns Lawrence’s contract; $2,000 is the current cap effect, not his total cost.

Rich

In the draft’s November 18 simulation of 10,000 seasons, Cross’s returned first-round pick lands at 1.05 in 32.0% of runs and 1.06 in 34.6%, 66.6% combined. His returned second-round pick follows the same positions, 2.05 or 2.06. The Keith Creelman first-round pick that Cross sent to Eric Martel lands at 1.07 in 30.4% and 1.08 in 26.3%, 56.7% combined. Cross’s own first reaches 1.01 in only 4.5%. That supports his case that he improved his first, and it is a gentle reminder to anyone getting excited about a top pick. These are estimates; they get rechecked if the forecast cutoff changes.

Hawk Tuah sideChampionship side
Slot123456789101112
Brian Cross’s 2027 first- and second-round picks back to Cross
Hawk Tuah side in all 10,000 runs (1.01–1.06 / 2.01–2.06)
4.57.78.512.732.034.6
Keith Creelman’s 2027 first-round pick to Eric Martel
3.6% Hawk Tuah side (1.01–1.06) · 96.4% championship side (1.07–1.12)
1.60.70.80.30.10.130.426.316.414.25.43.7
Derrick Whitman’s 2027 third-round pick to Eric Martel
45.7% Hawk Tuah side (3.01–3.06) · 54.3% championship side (3.07–3.12)
15.713.39.17.20.30.214.720.312.04.02.40.8
Eric Martel’s 2027 fifth-round pick to Cross
championship side in all 10,000 runs (5.07–5.12)
0.60.317.325.632.623.6

Estimates, not predictions: shares of 10,000 simulated seasons on the rosters after this trade (forecast generated Wed Nov 18, 1:46 PM ET, MFL data through Week 10). A season’s slot comes from that team’s own postseason bracket finish; the Hawk Tuah winner takes the first slot and the UPS champion the last. A blank cell is a slot the team never reached. Shares are rounded; the model moves every week.

ReceivesPlayer, pick or cap spaceSalaryYears leftStarts for the sender
Brian CrossJordan Addison (WR, MIN)$17,00010 of 10
Brian CrossBrian Cross’s 2027 first-round pick———
Brian CrossBrian Cross’s 2027 second-round pick———
Brian CrossEric Martel’s 2027 fifth-round pick———
Eric MartelTrevor Lawrence (QB, JAC)$37,00019 of 10
Eric MartelKeith Creelman’s 2027 first-round pick———
Eric MartelDerrick Whitman’s 2027 third-round pick———
Eric Martel$18,000 of cap space———

Source: MFL’s public transaction, roster and weekly-results exports; salary and years left are the players’ current MFL contracts; starts are weekly lineups through Week 10. The Playoff Picture below is the forecast on the post-trade rosters.

2 Division Week — 18 games, three sweeps, the widest margin 173.9 and the closest 12.2
Stuart

DOG POUND 4 LIFE v Maddie Mondays. Bear Dunn is the sweep, and you know that part. The pain is on the other side.

Rich

Keith Creelman scored 250.8 and went 2–1: beat Eric Mannila by 92.3, Chris Klingenberg by 76.3; lost to Bear Dunn by 58.1.

Stuart

Ryan Bousquet scored 232.5 and went 2–1: beat Eric Mannila by 74.0, Chris Klingenberg by 58.0; lost to Bear Dunn by 76.4.

Rich

Chris Klingenberg scored 174.5 and went 1–2: beat Josh Martel by 39.5; lost to Keith Creelman by 76.3, Ryan Bousquet by 58.0. Chris Klingenberg is 15–12 overall but 1–5 against the division. Everything won has been won somewhere else.

Stuart

Eric Mannila scored 158.5 and went 1–2: beat Josh Martel by 23.5; lost to Keith Creelman by 92.3, Ryan Bousquet by 74.0.

Rich

Josh Martel scored 135.0 and went 0–3: lost to Bear Dunn by 173.9, Chris Klingenberg by 39.5, Eric Mannila by 23.5. That was the lowest score of the week.

Rich

Keith Creelman and Chris Klingenberg are both 15–12, and the division is Creelman’s at 95.3% to Klingenberg’s <0.01%.

Rich

LEGION OF BOOM v Outlast PG Time. Shawn Blake scored 266.0 and went 3–0: beat Eric Martel by 72.7, Brian Cross by 61.4, Brian Cutting by 41.1.

Stuart

Matt Gerardi scored 240.7, with 48.1 from Patrick Mahomes, and went 3–0: beat Eric Martel by 47.4, Brian Cross by 36.1, Brian Cutting by 15.8.

Rich

Brian Cutting scored 224.9 and went 1–2: beat Derrick Whitman by 43.8; lost to Shawn Blake by 41.1, Matt Gerardi by 15.8.

Stuart

Brian Cross scored 204.6 and went 1–2: beat Derrick Whitman by 23.5; lost to Shawn Blake by 61.4, Matt Gerardi by 36.1.

Rich

Eric Martel scored 193.3 and went 1–2: beat Derrick Whitman by 12.2, the closest game of the week; lost to Shawn Blake by 72.7, Matt Gerardi by 47.4. That makes Eric Martel 6–0 against the division.

Stuart

Derrick Whitman scored 181.1 and went 0–3: lost to Brian Cutting by 43.8, Brian Cross by 23.5, Eric Martel by 12.2.

Stuart

Eric Martel is 20–7, and the forecast gives Eric Martel a better title chance, 23.6%, than Blake, 6.0%.

Rich

Which makes Brian Cross the story. Through Week 9, Cross was 22–77 in All-Play, tied for the fifth-worst start since 2011. Week 10 took Cross to 27–83, and 13 earlier teams were at that mark or worse by now, so the climb has left the all-time basement. It is still the worst start of that owner’s career in the archive, 9 games under the 36–74 in 2025.

DivisionSweptSplitShut out
DOG POUND 4 LIFE v Maddie MondaysBear Dunn 308.9Keith Creelman 250.8, Ryan Bousquet 232.5, Chris Klingenberg 174.5, Eric Mannila 158.5Josh Martel 135.0
LEGION OF BOOM v Outlast PG TimeShawn Blake 266.0, Matt Gerardi 240.7Brian Cutting 224.9, Brian Cross 204.6, Eric Martel 193.3Derrick Whitman 181.1

Week 10 scores. A team is Swept when it won every game it played in the group, Shut out when it won none and Split otherwise. History lines use the league archive of weekly results (2010 is left out because its archived scores conflict with themselves). Chat lines are owner posts in the league Discord, linked to the message.

3 Elias — official statistics changes
Stuart

Elias posted five official statistics changes Wednesday at 11:14 PM ET. Three of them changed the score of a rostered player, and all three were nonstarters. No team score, result, ranking or All-Play changed, so Week 10 stands as played.

4 Playoff Picture — updated after Week 10
Stuart

Here is the shape of it. Four division leaders: Bear Dunn at 99.99% to win Dog Pound 4 Life, Eric Martel at 99.1%, Keith Creelman at 95.3%, and Shawn Blake at 93.7%.

Rich

Then the wild-card road. Brian Cutting is 99.6% with a 0.9% division chance, and Cutting is counting entirely on a wild card. Derrick Whitman is 54.3% to make the playoffs with only a 6.3% chance of winning the division, so Whitman gets in the other way. Chris Klingenberg is 36.4% and Mannila 8.7%.

Stuart

And the bottom: Ryan Bousquet is at 5.3%, Matt Gerardi at <0.01%, Brian Cross at <0.01%, and Josh Martel at <0.01%.

FranchisePlayoffsFirst-round byeWins divisionTitle
C-Town ChivalryBear Dunn99.99%99.99%99.99%52.2%
HammerTime 🔨 ⏰Eric Martel99.99%97.4%99.1%23.6%
Pure GreatnessBrian Cutting99.6%0.7%0.9%13.4%
Blake BombersShawn Blake99.3%1.8%93.7%6.0%
Real Deal CreelKeith Creelman96.4%0.04%95.3%3.7%
CBPDerrick Whitman54.3%<0.01%6.3%0.9%
HawksChris Klingenberg36.4%<0.01%<0.01%0.2%
Cleon Ca$hEric Mannila8.7%<0.01%<0.01%0.02%
L.A. LooksRyan Bousquet5.3%<0.01%4.7%0.04%
GrideMatt Gerardi<0.01%<0.01%<0.01%<0.01%
The Long HaulersBrian Cross<0.01%<0.01%<0.01%<0.01%
Sex MantherJosh Martel<0.01%<0.01%<0.01%<0.01%

Probabilities updated after Week 10 (Wed Nov 18, 1:46 PM ET), 10,000 simulated seasons. One team wins each division in every simulated season; division odds and the league’s title odds are rounded so each group still adds up to the whole. A probability prints as certain only when the outcome is clinched or eliminated; a figure that would round to certain prints to two decimals, or as <0.01%.

5 The Plays That Made the Week — the bargains, the busts, and who they carried
Stuart

Start with the number nobody had. George Pickens was projected for 10.1 and scored 46.9 for Ryan Bousquet. That is +36.8, the biggest bargain of the week. Dallas Turner added 15.5 against a 6.0 projection.

Rich

Dak Prescott was projected for 17.1 and scored 49.2 for Keith Creelman, another big bargain. Patrick Mahomes, Matt Gerardi’s quarterback, was projected for 16.3 and put up 48.1. Joe Burrow, Bear Dunn’s quarterback, was projected for 15.9 and put up 47.5.

Stuart

Now the other side. Bear Dunn started Brock Bowers and Chase Young, projected for 20.4 and 8.2, and got 5.2 and 1.5 from them. That is 21.9 projected points that never showed up, and Bear Dunn still scored 308.9 and went 3–0.

Stuart

On defense, Maxx Crosby gave Brian Cross 20.5 on a 7.0 projection.

Week 10 play of the week
Christian McCaffrey
C-Town Chivalry
51.9UPS points · Bear Dunn
Christian McCaffrey
RB · SF vs DAL

13 carries for 62 and 1 TD; 4 catches on 4 targets for 161 and 2 TD

Watch verified NFL highlights ↗
Week 10 play of the week
Patrick Mahomes
Gride
48.1UPS points · Matt Gerardi
Patrick Mahomes
QB · KC vs ATL

22-of-35 for 348, 5 TD; 2 carries for 15

The full projection ledger

Offense busts Projected → scored

  1. Bear DunnBrock Bowers (TE, Bear Dunn)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:05 PM ET20.4 → 5.2-15.2
  2. Brian CuttingDrake Maye (QB, Brian Cutting)MFL proj. Fri 2:31 PM ET · kickoff Sun 9:30 AM ET16.9 → 3.4-13.5
  3. Chris KlingenbergKyren Williams (RB, Chris Klingenberg)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:05 PM ET17.5 → 5.0-12.5
  4. Eric MartelTrey McBride (TE, Eric Martel)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:05 PM ET23.8 → 11.6-12.2
  5. Eric MannilaChristian Watson (WR, Eric Mannila)MFL proj. Sun 12:37 PM ET · kickoff Sun 1:00 PM ET17.1 → 7.1-10.0

Offense bargains Projected → scored

  1. Ryan BousquetGeorge Pickens (WR, Ryan Bousquet)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:25 PM ET10.1 → 46.9+36.8
  2. Keith CreelmanDak Prescott (QB, Keith Creelman)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:25 PM ET17.1 → 49.2+32.1
  3. Matt GerardiPatrick Mahomes (QB, Matt Gerardi)MFL proj. Sun 12:37 PM ET · kickoff Sun 1:00 PM ET16.3 → 48.1+31.8
  4. Bear DunnJoe Burrow (QB, Bear Dunn)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 8:20 PM ET15.9 → 47.5+31.6
  5. Bear DunnChristian McCaffrey (RB, Bear Dunn)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:25 PM ET21.7 → 51.9+30.2

Defense busts Projected → scored

  1. Eric MartelQuentin Lake (DB, Eric Martel)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:05 PM ET11.5 → 2.1-9.4
  2. Ryan BousquetMinkah Fitzpatrick (DB, Ryan Bousquet)MFL proj. Sun 12:37 PM ET · kickoff Sun 1:00 PM ET9.5 → 2.1-7.4
  3. Josh MartelNick Scott (DB, Josh Martel)MFL proj. Sun 12:37 PM ET · kickoff Sun 1:00 PM ET8.1 → 1.3-6.8
  4. Brian CuttingMyles Garrett (DL, Brian Cutting)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:05 PM ET6.7 → 0.0-6.7
  5. Bear DunnChase Young (DL, Bear Dunn)MFL proj. Sun 12:37 PM ET · kickoff Sun 1:00 PM ET8.2 → 1.5-6.7

Defense bargains Projected → scored

  1. Brian CrossMaxx Crosby (DL, Brian Cross)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:05 PM ET7.0 → 20.5+13.5
  2. Shawn BlakeCedric Gray (LB, Shawn Blake)MFL proj. Sun 12:37 PM ET · kickoff Sun 1:00 PM ET6.5 → 16.5+10.0
  3. Ryan BousquetDallas Turner (DL, Ryan Bousquet)MFL proj. Sun 12:37 PM ET · kickoff Sun 1:00 PM ET6.0 → 15.5+9.5
  4. Brian CuttingAndrew Van Ginkel (DL, Brian Cutting)MFL proj. Sun 12:37 PM ET · kickoff Sun 1:00 PM ET6.5 → 15.5+9.0
  5. Brian CrossDevon Witherspoon (DB, Brian Cross)MFL proj. Sun 3:06 PM ET · kickoff Sun 4:05 PM ET7.8 → 15.7+7.9

Started players only. Projection source: each player’s last MFL projection saved before his own kickoff, captured Thu Nov 12, 7:53 PM ET, Fri Nov 13, 2:31 PM ET, Sun Nov 15, 12:37 PM ET and later; every row shows its capture time and the player’s own kickoff, and every capture came first. 192 offensive and defensive starters graded; 0 not graded for want of a pregame capture. Largest gaps among graded starters, not every starter.

6 The Season So Far — who is real, who is rising, and what history says
Stuart

Treat the last three weeks as their own season. In Weeks 8–10, Bear Dunn is 32–1 in All-Play. That is the only Dominant team in the league. The next best are Eric Martel at 25–8 and Shawn Blake at 21–12.

Rich

The movers. Ryan Bousquet climbed from tenth in scoring in Weeks 1–7 to sixth in Weeks 8–10. Keith Creelman climbed from sixth in scoring in Weeks 1–7 to third in Weeks 8–10. Derrick Whitman fell from fifth to tenth and is 8–25 over the stretch. Brian Cross went from ninth to twelfth.

Stuart

Then ask what history says about where everyone sits after Week 10. The Survival Line looks at past seasons: of teams with Eric Martel’s All-Play rank at this point, 18 of 20 made the playoffs; Bear Dunn’s group, 18 of 20; Brian Cutting’s group, 17 of 18; Shawn Blake’s group, 17 of 18.

Stuart

At the bottom, Brian Cross is 1 of 17 by All-Play rank and 0 of 8 by wins, and Josh Martel is 1 of 17 and 0 of 8. Both are at <0.01%. Matt Gerardi is 3 of 17 and 0 of 8, with odds of <0.01%.

Rich

And luck. Josh Martel is +1.8 wins over what the All-Play rate predicts, the most in the league, and Shawn Blake is −1.4, the fewest (Brian Cutting is level at that figure). Brian Cutting leaves 41.5 points on the bench every week, also the most, and 7 of 12 losses would have been wins with the best lineup.

The standings, Heat Check and Survival Line tables
FranchiseDivisionRecordWeek 10 all-playAll-playPoints for
C-Town ChivalryBear Dunnleader24–311–099–112,732.0
HammerTime 🔨 ⏰Eric Martelleader20–74–781–292,447.4
Blake BombersShawn Blakeleader16–1110–169–412,289.8
Pure GreatnessBrian Cutting15–126–566–442,253.8
Real Deal CreelKeith Creelmanleader15–129–259–512,209.2
HawksChris Klingenberg15–122–957–532,026.3
CBPDerrick Whitman13–143–857–532,097.4
Cleon Ca$hEric Mannila13–141–1049–612,026.4
L.A. LooksRyan Bousquet11–167–440–701,955.0
GrideMatt Gerardi7–208–332–781,859.7
The Long HaulersBrian Cross6–215–627–831,856.2
Sex MantherJosh Martel7–200–1124–861,780.7

In the same order as the league standings page: the current playoff field first (division leaders take the top two places), then everyone else; every place goes by all-play percentage, then overall record, then points for, then head-to-head.

Week 10 matchupOur favoriteFinalCalled it?
Bear Dunn vs Josh MartelBear Dunn (97%)308.9–135.0yes
Bear Dunn vs Ryan BousquetBear Dunn (86%)308.9–232.5yes
Chris Klingenberg vs Josh MartelChris Klingenberg (85%)174.5–135.0yes
Bear Dunn vs Keith CreelmanBear Dunn (81%)308.9–250.8yes
Shawn Blake vs Brian CrossShawn Blake (80%)266.0–204.6yes
Eric Mannila vs Josh MartelEric Mannila (77%)158.5–135.0yes
Eric Martel vs Matt GerardiEric Martel (75%)193.3–240.7no
Eric Martel vs Derrick WhitmanEric Martel (74%)193.3–181.1yes
Brian Cutting vs Matt GerardiBrian Cutting (74%)224.9–240.7no
Brian Cutting vs Derrick WhitmanBrian Cutting (74%)224.9–181.1yes
Keith Creelman vs Eric MannilaKeith Creelman (63%)250.8–158.5yes
Chris Klingenberg vs Ryan BousquetChris Klingenberg (59%)174.5–232.5no
Derrick Whitman vs Brian CrossDerrick Whitman (58%)181.1–204.6no
Matt Gerardi vs Brian CrossMatt Gerardi (57%)240.7–204.6yes
Ryan Bousquet vs Eric MannilaRyan Bousquet (53%)232.5–158.5yes
Shawn Blake vs Brian CuttingShawn Blake (51%)266.0–224.9yes
Eric Martel vs Shawn BlakeEric Martel (51%)193.3–266.0no
Keith Creelman vs Chris KlingenbergKeith Creelman (51%)250.8–174.5yes

Last week’s published preview, graded against the final scores: favorites won 13 of 18.

Team
Reading
All-Play
Wks 8–10
(season)
Scoring rank
Wks 1–7 → Wks 8–10
Bear Dunn
Dominant
32–1
(99–11)
1st → 1st
Eric Martel
Holding
25–8
(81–29)
2nd → 2nd
Shawn Blake
Holding
21–12
(69–41)
3rd → 4th
Keith Creelman
Holding
20–13
(59–51)
6th → 3rd
Brian Cutting
Holding
18–15
(66–44)
4th → 5th
Ryan Bousquet
Rising
16–17
(40–70)
10th → 6th
Chris Klingenberg
Holding
15–18
(57–53)
7th → 8th
Eric Mannila
Holding
15–18
(49–61)
8th → 7th
Matt Gerardi
Holding
12–21
(32–78)
11th → 9th
Josh Martel
Holding
10–23
(24–86)
12th → 11th
Derrick Whitman
Cooling
8–25
(57–53)
5th → 10th
Brian Cross
Holding
6–27
(27–83)
9th → 12th

Sorted by All-Play over Weeks 8–10; the full-season All-Play record is in parentheses. Reading, applied in order: Dominant = at least 28 of every 33 all-play games in that stretch; Sinking = 5 of every 33 or fewer; Rising / Cooling = scoring rank moved four or more places; otherwise Holding.

TeamLeft on bench / wkLosses the best lineup would have wonWins vs expected
Brian Cutting41.57 of 12−1.4
Eric Martel30.13 of 7+0.5
Chris Klingenberg28.52 of 12+0.9
Matt Gerardi28.48 of 20−0.5
Ryan Bousquet26.36 of 16+1.3
Keith Creelman26.35 of 12−0.0
Shawn Blake25.85 of 11−1.4
Derrick Whitman24.85 of 14−1.3
Eric Mannila23.86 of 14+1.7
Josh Martel22.76 of 20+1.8
Bear Dunn20.32 of 3−0.8
Brian Cross18.54 of 21−0.9

Bench points = the best possible lineup from the same roster, known only after the games, minus the lineup started. Wins vs expected = head-to-head wins minus the wins each week’s all-play rate would give.

TeamCategory, playoffsMade it from the same All-Play rank, 2017–2025Made it with the same win total, 2021–2025
Eric MartelContender
99.99%
18/2010/11
Bear DunnContender
99.99%
18/207/7
Brian CuttingContender
99.6%
17/1810/18
Shawn BlakeContender
99.3%
17/1810/18
Keith CreelmanContender
96.4%
12/1610/18
Derrick WhitmanIn the race
54.3%
12/1610/18
Chris KlingenbergIn the race
36.4%
12/1610/18
Eric MannilaNeeds a run
8.7%
3/2010/18
Ryan BousquetLife support
5.3%
3/173/16
Matt GerardiLife support
<0.01%
3/170/8
Brian CrossLife support
<0.01%
1/170/8
Josh MartelLife support
<0.01%
1/170/8

“Made it”: teams in the same position after Week 10 of a past season who went on to make the playoffs, out of all such teams. All-Play rank is grouped in pairs (tied teams share the higher rank); win totals are grouped in five bands, among seasons with the same number of games so far. Categories come from this week’s playoff odds: Contender 90% or better, In the field 60–90, In the race 25–60, Needs a run 8–25, Life support under 8.

7 Side bet · Cross vs. Josh Martel
Stuart

Brian Cross and Josh Martel have two separate $50 bets. The first is whether the Long Haulers make the playoffs. The second is whether Jalen Hurts and Trevor Lawrence outscore Caleb Williams and Lamar Jackson in total UPS fantasy points through Week 17. Cross set out the terms in the chat on September 3, and on September 21 he said they were riding it out with no changes. No quarterback is substituted. Both bets are unsettled.

Rich

After Week 10, Cross’s pair has 332.0 points and Josh Martel’s has 232.7. Cross leads by 99.3. The count is every UPS point the four quarterbacks score, started or not, and it follows them through trades: Jackson moved teams earlier and Lawrence moved after Week 10, and neither changes whose total the points go to.

Stuart

The playoff bet: the forecast gives the Long Haulers odds of <0.01% to make the field. It settles when the official playoff field is set.

Rich

Josh Martel led after Week 1. Cross took the lead in Week 3, with Williams out. Week 5 moved the lead by 44.8 toward Cross: Cross’s pair scored 44.8 to Josh Martel’s 0.0, with Williams out and Jackson out. Week 10 moved the lead by 36.6 toward Cross: Cross’s pair scored 36.6 to Josh Martel’s 0.0, with Williams on a bye and Jackson out.

Brian CrossThe Long Haulers
Jalen Hurts, PHI quarterback
Jalen Hurts
Trevor Lawrence, JAC quarterback
Trevor Lawrence
332.0points through Week 10
vs.
Josh MartelSex Manther
Caleb Williams, CHI quarterback
Caleb Williams
Lamar Jackson, BAL quarterback
Lamar Jackson
232.7points through Week 10
  • Caleb Williams, Week 2: Hurt his right hamstring late in the Week 2 loss to Minnesota; coach Ben Johnson called him week to week. Bears, September 21
  • Lamar Jackson, Week 4: Left the Week 4 game against Tennessee at halftime with an ankle injury. AP, October 4
  • Jalen Hurts, Week 6: Placed on injured reserve with a blood clot in his calf; the team gave no return date. Eagles, October 17
  • Lamar Jackson, Week 8: Returned for Week 8 at Buffalo and hurt his right thumb on the first snap; he scored zero. AP, November 1
  • Lamar Jackson, Week 9: Placed on injured reserve; the team said he would miss at least four games and no return date was given. Ravens, November 5
  • Lamar Jackson, fantasy trade on September 29: Josh Martel to Cutting. The points still count for the same bet side.
  • Trevor Lawrence, fantasy trade on November 17: Cross to Eric Martel. The points still count for the same bet side.

Status checked November 18 from each team’s own page or an AP report; no return date is given unless the team gave one.

Week-by-week UPS points for the four quarterbacks, the pair totals, the cumulative totals and the lead (Cross minus Josh Martel)
WeekHurtsLawrenceCross QBsWilliamsJacksonJosh QBsCross totalJosh totalLead
Wk 130.235.866.043.929.873.766.073.7−7.7
Wk 222.66.429.07.316.523.895.097.5−2.5
Wk 313.227.841.0OUT27.227.2136.0124.7+11.3
Wk 416.216.032.2OUT23.623.6168.2148.3+19.9
Wk 517.027.844.8OUTOUT0.0213.0148.3+64.7
Wk 6OUT39.739.718.6OUT18.6252.7166.9+85.8
Wk 7OUTBYE0.028.0OUT28.0252.7194.9+57.8
Wk 8OUT23.923.917.60.017.6276.6212.5+64.1
Wk 9OUT18.818.820.2OUT20.2295.4232.7+62.7
Wk 10BYE36.636.6BYEOUT0.0332.0232.7+99.3
Wk 11pending
Wk 12pending
Wk 13pending
Wk 14pending
Wk 15pending
Wk 16pending
Wk 17pending

UPS fantasy points from MFL’s full player-score export, started or not, regular season and playoffs through Week 17. OUT = the quarterback’s team played and he has no score; BYE = his team had no game; a posted 0.0 means he played and scored zero. Points follow each quarterback through fantasy trades. Rechecked after every Elias change; the totals are provisional until Week 17 is final.

8 Hall of Shame watch
Stuart

The Hall of Shame takes any team whose final All-Play percentage, counted through all 17 weeks and playoffs included, is below .200. With twelve teams, each team has 187 comparisons, so 38 wins is the fewest that stays at or above .200 with no ties. After Week 10, 77 comparisons remain for each team.

Rich

This is All-Play arithmetic, not playoff odds. A tie counts as half a win. The list updates after each completed week from MFL’s official standings, so an Elias change that moves a score moves it too; a team is inducted only when Week 17 ends below the line.

Josh MartelCandidate
24 winsneeds 14 more in the next 77 comparisonsrecord 24-86-0
Brian CrossCandidate
27 winsneeds 11 more in the next 77 comparisonsrecord 27-83-0
Matt GerardiCandidate
32 winsneeds 6 more in the next 77 comparisonsrecord 32-78-0

Bar = current All-Play wins (solid), wins still needed to reach the safe line (striped), then the remaining comparisons; the vertical line is the safe line. Teams below .300 All-Play are listed. Candidate = can still finish below the line; inducted = the season ended below it. Source: MFL standings and league settings; any playoff week MFL does not count is counted from that week’s official team scores.

Previous Hall of Shame seasons

Stuart

Chris Klingenberg appears twice. The 2024 franchise’s .107 is the lowest of these four.

SeasonOwner of recordAll-PlayPercentageWeeks counted
2011Eric Mannila19–124.13313
2014Chris Klingenberg28–115.19613
2018Chris Klingenberg29–147.16516
2024Josh Lima†20–167.10717

Previous seasons below .200, from the league’s canonical All-Play record: the regular season through 2016 and the full season from 2017, so each season counts the weeks the league actually counted. Weeks counted = comparisons divided by eleven. Owner of record = the owner who built the auction roster (league rule). Source: src_standings.allplay_historical_*.

† 2024: Lima built the roster; Cross took over before Week 1.

How this was built — 3 notes
Sources. MFL scores, standings, schedules, transactions and Elias posts; the league’s D1 copies, checked against MFL; MFL projections as saved before each kickoff; nflverse expected points; the archived league Discord.
Status. Automated draft (ups_center_auto.py), generated Thu Nov 19, 7:56 AM ET. Not published.